Tuesday, May 1, 2012

Catholics for Choice Killed a Strawman

Remember my post about Catholic Butts? One of the smelliest derrieres out there is the oxymoronic Catholics for Choice


A brief summary the essay linked above: contraception isn't abortifacient, because pregnancy doesn't begin until implantation. Therefore, contraception is OK. The end.

She provides no evidence, other than "because the ACOG says so," to support her assertions. What's interesting is this article from the American Journal of OB/GYNs stating that over half of OB-GYNS who responded (57%) believe that life begins at conception. Only 28% believe pregnancy begins at implantation (16% weren't sure, apparently). It seems that ACOG's official stance doesn't necessarily reflect the beliefs of most OB/GYNs! Imagine that.

She makes no mention of when human life begins. If she believes that life begins at implantation, and not conception, there's a wealth of scientific evidence to the contrary.

She also makes the ludicrous claim that she and her husband, both intelligent scientists, had an inordinate amount of difficulty grasping the difference between "user failure rates" and "method failure rates" when comparing NFP to contraception. I'm a woman of average intelligence with an English degree, and I didn't find the concept that difficult to comprehend. Moreover, she provides no evidence to support her claim that the 99% correct use efficacy of NFP is "a lie." (It's not.)

There is also no discussion whatsoever about the moral aspect of contraception, abortifacient or otherwise. I doubt she's ever heard of Theology of the Body. She seems profoundly ignorant of the fact that Catholic Church teaching on contraception does not rest on the premise that hormonal contraception is abortifacient, but rather that contraception of any type violates the integrity and sanctity of the marital act.

In my opinion, this was the most tragic part of the entire essay:
I plan on going to confession and hearing the priest out. And unless he flatly forbids it, I also plan on taking Communion. Because I am morally sure, in my heart, that for me, this is the proper decision.
Truth is not founded upon the feelings in one's heart. Otherwise all manner of evils could be justified (for example, what if a woman feels morally sure, in her heart, that her adulterous affair with her married lover is the proper decision?).

Let's pray that this woman finds a holy and orthodox priest who will guide her to the Church's teachings about a fully informed conscience and the intrinsic moral evil of contraception.

7 comments:

  1. awesome post! i wanna link it in the comments of the article! :)

    ReplyDelete
  2. that entire article is just her trying to convince herself, rather than anyone else, that using bc is just fine. sad, sad story.

    ReplyDelete
  3. I gasped out loud when I read the part in blue...oh dear....prayer, prayer prayer. This makes me sad.

    ReplyDelete
  4. That girl's mindset is just so typical of many 'ordinary' Catholics here in Ireland-a sort of self appointed dispensation from Church teaching, particularly in the area of Marriage along with an abysmal ignorance of practically anything the Church teaches about anything, leading to the terrible sufferings we are experiencing here. I firmly believe that catecesis is a huge tool in the re-evangelisation of the western world.Great post, clear and to the point. Jen x

    ReplyDelete
  5. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete
  6. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete
  7. One of our priests, an elderly misguided one at that, stated from the pulpit that the use of contraception is a loving thing to do. (face plant) Just last week he stated that the only real sin is selfishness. (gasp) In the past he proudly stated that he was disobeying the bishops by speaking out against the church about priest abuse. I could go on, but I'm still in shock. Please keep him, and all priests and religious in your prayers.

    ReplyDelete

Please be respectful and courteous, and I will reciprocate.

Note to commenters: sometimes long comments, or comments that contain links, are sent to the comment moderation folder (or sometimes the spam folder). If you comment and it doesn't show up right away, chances are it went to comment moderation or spam. Rather than re-posting your comment, please e-mail me and ask me to check these folders. Thanks!